>> Version
zum Drucken (pop-up)
Nuclearisation in Europe and the Middle East – From threat to preventive action - Concluding Statement
Avoiding another war in Iran - a Nuclear Weapon Free Zone in the Middle East - Nuclear weapon free zone in Europe - Strengthening the NPT
Upon invitation of the Swiss chapter of the International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War (IPPNW, Nobel peace prize 1985), an international conference on the topic of “Nuclearisation in Europe and the Middle East” took place on Monte Verità, Ascona, Switzerland from March 22nd to 25th 2007.
In a time of high international tension in the Middle East, participants focused on the absolute necessity for high-level constructive dialogue between all the parties. Respect for mutual fears as well as the overcoming of misunderstandings due to cultural and historical differences should inherently be part of such dialogue. It is feared that threatening arguments on both sides could lead to escalation. A preemptive strike policy and the use of military force however, would have catastrophic consequences for the local population. Moreover, it would have serious political repercussions, promote nuclear proliferation and further destabilise the entire region. The world needs a stable Iran, just as Iran needs cooperation with the rest of the international community.
One feasible way to stabilise the region would be the establishment of a nuclear weapon free zone (NWFZ), an idea proposed by Iran and Egypt in 1974 and discussed repeatedly and promoted in the United Nations and Non Proliferation Treaty (NPT) review conferences. It was noted that a single leading country, even a single city could stimulate a NWFZ in the Middle East. In order to guarantee that the nuclear weapons states respect the provisions of the NWFZ, consultations are required. Even if only a symbolic act initially, it could bring about a new situation and break the political deadlock. Obviously, such a zone must eventually cover the entire Middle East.
NATO`s nuclear doctrine includes optional first use of nuclear weapons and their stationing in European non-nuclear weapon states. This doctrine was questioned, as it is based on a strategic concept which may be detrimental to European security. It is considered that nuclear weapons on European territory nowadays cannot be justified. In the interest of new thinking on security in Europe and a doctrine change, the voice of Non Nuclear Weapon states (NNWS) of the NATO alliance should be heard more often, and public opposition to nuclear weapons respected. A NWFZ in Europe would be a significant step towards a nuclear weapon free world.
Finally, participants discussed the ever important role of the Non Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in its verification functions. The danger of a further erosion of the NPT, due to the worrisome absence of progress in nuclear disarmament by non-fulfillment of the nuclear weapon states obligations with article VI, was emphasised. The NNWS should play a stronger role in the implementation and evolution of the NPT, particularly prior to the next review conference in 2010. In this context, discussions between representatives of the NNWS, IPPNW, the Inter- national Association of Lawyers Against Nuclear Arms (IALANA) and the International Network of Engineers and Scientists Against Proliferation (INESAP) were proposed.
Ascona, march 24th 2007
Signed by
Andreas Nidecker, Professor of Radiology, Basel, Switzerland
Günter Baitsch, Internal Medicine, Basel, Switzerland
Martin Walter, Internal Medicine, Grenchen, Switzerland
Arthur Muhl, Chiropractor, Au, Switzerland
Urs Peter Frey, General Medicine, St. Gallen, Switzerland
Claudio Knüsli, Basel, President PSR/IPPNW Switzerland
Cornelia Hesse-Honegger, Artist, Switzerland
Saideh Lotfian, Professor of Law, Tehran, Iran
Ronnee Jaeger, Bat Shalom, Israel
Gunnar Westberg Co-President IPPNW, Sweden
Esther R. Suter, Pastor, Switzerland
Trygve Berge, medical student / Editor IPPNW Norway Magazine
Margret Johannsen, Peace Researcher, Hamburg, Germany
Frida Sundberg, President SLMK (IPPNW Sweden), Sweden
Klas Lundius, Director SLMK (IPPNW Sweden), Sweden
Herman Spanjaard, Former Vice President Europe IPPNW, Netherlands
Alyn Ware, Global Coordinator, Parliamentary Network for Nuclear
Disarmament, New Zealand
Marianne Baitsch, Nurse, Switzerland
Mina Ennasri, Psychotherapeute Etudiante, IPPNW France
André Michel, Medical Student, MedAction Ireland, Dublin, Ireland
Marcela Fejgl, Pathologist, Sion, Switzerland
Gert Harigel, Senior Physicist emerit. CERN, Geneva, Switzerland
>top
Programme
Nuclearisation in Europe and the Middle East – From threat to
preventive action
Monte Verità,Ascona,Switzerland,March 22–25,2007
Thursday March 22nd
16.00 – 18.00 Arrival followed by informal get together
20.00 Dinner
>top
Friday March 23rd
Morning Session
08.30 - 12.15
08.00 Registration
08.30 Welcome by Dr. Claudio Knüsli, President PSR / IPPNW Switzerland
Growing nuclearisation (Power and Weapons) – links to public health.
Welcome by Dr. Gunnar Westberg, Co-President IPPNW
History of the IPPNW, in particular the story of mediation between the SU and the USA during the times of the cold war
09.15
Prof. Saideh Lotfian : Nuclearisation in the Middle East: from threat to
preventive action
09.35
Discussion
09.45
Dr. Jochen Bittner : The second Nuclear Age – Why the coming decades will
be more precarious than the Cold War era.
10.05
Discussion
10.15
Ronnie Jaeger : Attacking as victim?! What could be the basis for
respectful dialogue?
10.35
Discussion
10.45 Coffee
11.15
Minister Andreas Friedrich : Switzerland and nuclear arms control : views
and contributions
11.35
Discussion
11.45
Dr. Margret Johannsen : Mutual distrust and threats - Is there a chance
for dialogue ?
12.05
Discussion
12.30 Lunch
Afternoon Session
14.00 - 18.00
Chair: Prof. Dr. Andreas Nidecker
14.00 Dr. Hossein Mousavian : Security by NW in the Middle East? Reducing
the current threat. „Regional NWFZ in the Middle East“. If possible,
what would be the role of the IAEA?
14.20 Discussion
14.30 Prof. Dr. Albert A. Stahel : Strategic conceptions behind the nuclear
armaments
14.50 Discussion
15.00 Alyn Ware :Overview of NWFZ.
15.20 Dr. Ime John : How the African continent became a NWFZ
15.40 Ian Kenyon/ Dr. Mustafa Alani : A Nuclear Weapon
Free Zone in the Middle East ?
16.10 Discussion of the three papers
16.40 Coffee
17.00 Prof. Dr. Harald Müller : Security by NW in Europe. Is the NATO
doctrine still relevant?
17.20 Discussion
17.30 Bascha Mika : Nuclear Weapons in the media.
17.50-18.00 Discussion
19.00 Dinner/ Cultural Programme
>top
Saturday March 24th
Morning Session
09.00 - 12.00
Chair : Dr. Hossein Mousavian
09.00
Werner van Gent : Proliferation-Control and the Main Conflicts in
the Middle East
09.20 Discussion
09.30
Tariq Rauf (invited) :The future of NPT - what can NGOs like IPPNW
contribute?
09.50 Discussion
10.00 Dr. Bruno Pellaud : The challenge: the civilian and the military
dimensions of nuclear energy.The dual role of the IAEA: could the IAEA
depart from its assignment to promote civil nuclear energy?
10.20 Discussion
10.30 Coffee
11.00 Sergey Batsanov : UN – WHO – IAEA : are new treaties needed?
11.20 Discussion
11.30 M.D.Shariar Khateri : Chemical and Biological weapons in the Middle East:
health and environmental impacts and lessons learnt
11.50 Discussion
12.00 Dr. Gert Harigel: Depleted Uranium
12.20 Discussion
12.30 Lunch
Afternoon Session
14.15 -18.45
Panel discussion :From Brainstorming to Action
Chair: Lotfian, Mika, Nidecker
Participants: Müller, Jaeger, Pellaud, Stahel, Johannsen,
Mousavian, v. Gent
14.15 More respect, how can it be reached?
15.15 From local to regional NWFZ to a better NPT.
16.15 Coffee
16.45 The future of the IAEA. - NPT 2010
17.45 Summary : Lotfian, Mika, Nidecker
19.30 Dinner
>top
Sunday March 25th
09.00 Task group :Action Plan
12.00 Lunch and End of Conference
>top
Organizers
Baitsch, Günter, Dr. med., PSR / IPPNW Switzerland, Pfaffenlohweg 21,
4125 Riehen, Switzerland, baitsch@magnet.ch
Knüsli, Claudio, Dr. med., PSR / IPPNW Switzerland, Gotthardstrasse 112,
CH-4054 Basel, Switzerland, claudio.knuesli@claraspital.ch
Nidecker,Andreas, Prof. Dr. med., PSR / IPPNW Switzerland, Ob. Rheinweg
81, CH-4058 Basel, Switzerland, andreas.nidecker@imamed.ch
>top
Speakers
Alani, Mustafa, Dr., Senior Adviser & Program Director, Gulf Research
Center,187 Oud Metha Tower, 11th Floor, 303 Sheikh Rashid Road, P.O. Box
80758, Dubai, UAE, alani@grc.ae
Batsanov, Sergey, Director, Geneva Office Pugwash Conferences on
Science and World Affaires, La Voie Creuse 16, 1202 Geneva, Switzerland,
pugwash.GE@gcsp.ch
Bittner, Jochen, Dr., Political Editor, die Zeit, 20095 Hamburg,
bittner@zeit.de
Friedrich, Andreas, Minister, Head Arms Control and Disarmament
Section, State Secretariat, Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs,
CH-3003 Bern, Switzerland, zisp-a@eda.admin.ch
Harigel, Gert G., Dr., Senior physicist emeritus, CERN, PH-Division,
1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland, Gert.Harigel@CERN.CH
Jaeger, Ronnie, Bat Shalom,The Jerusalem Women’s Action Center, King
George 14, P.O. Box 2426, Jerusalem 91023, Israel info@batshalom.org
Johannsen, Margret, Dr., Senior Fellow, Institute for Peace Research and
Safety Policy at the University of Hamburg, Falkenstein 1, D-22587 Hamburg,
Germany, johannsen@ifsh.de
John, Ime A., MD, MPH, Co-President IPPNW, Department of Public Health
of Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden, imejohn@yahoo.com
Khateri, Shariar, M.D., Society for chemical weapons victims support
(scwvs), P.O. Box 19615/619,Teheran, Iran, s_khateri@hotmail.com,
khateri@scwvs.org
Kenyon, Ian, Mountbatten, Centre for international studies, Departement
of Politics, University of Southampton, S017 IBJ Southampton, UK,
mcis@soton.ac.uk
>top
Contact
PSR / IPPNW Schweiz, Klosterberg 23, 4051 Basel, Switzerland
Phone / Fax ++41 61 271 50 25, sekretariat@ippnw.ch
>top
Coordination
Günter Baitsch, Phone / Fax ++41 61 271 50 25, baitsch@magnet.ch
>top
Meeting Place
Monte Verità, Ascona, Italian Part of Switzerland
200 km from Zurich Airport, 120 km from Milan Central Station
www.monteverita.org
>top
|